mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 1, 2023 19:09:47 GMT -5
Hello, Has anyone towed KZ Sportsmen Classic/Escape 160rbt with Class 2 hitch successfully and safely? I'm aware that most, if not everyone?, towing these trailer would tow them with Class 3, but my car can't have Class 3 hitch for my model in the U.S. My car's towing capacity is ~4400 lbs (thought it's not the official number as formerly my car isn't even rated to tow in the US). In the US, there are only Class I and Class II after-market hitches available for my car. - I have successfully towed our 1994 Mustang Palomino DD pop-up (very roomy but ~1600-1700lbs dry weight) on multiple occasions with my Curt Class I hitch
- I even towed 2012 Coachmen Clipper Classic (Expandable) 1285 SST w/dry weight of 2800 lbs 3500 lbs gross hitch weight 280 tongue weight with the same Curt Class I hitch as well. This 2012 Coachmen was our "experiment" to see if we can tow and want to buy a pop-up in the first place.
Now I'm upgrading my Curt Class I hitch to Class 2 Stealth Hitch (3500 lbs towing 350 lbs capacity) and installing 7 pin lighting and the brake controller. The question: - Assuming KZ Sportsmen Classic or Escape 160rbt has the necessary brakes installed, can I tow it with my new Class 2 hitch? I know renters on Outdoorsy would rent me one asking that I need Class 3 hitch, but is it truly needed?
I understand that's the safest setup but I really do't want to give up on my dream of owning a hybrid camping without giving up my car that I tow it as we love it - it's a 7 seater w/German engineering, drives super nicely, smaller profile than other 7 seaters available on the market. We live in Chicago so owning a truck or a bigger 7-seater SUV may not be a suitable option in general.
- If you haven't towed one with Class 2 yourself, would you give it a go given the circumstances and specs above for this setup?
Thank you for your feedback and responses in advance!
***Don't want to give up on my dream of safely towing a hybrid camper with my current car! (yet)***
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 1, 2023 20:01:09 GMT -5
That camper has a dry hitch weight of 340 lbs. Load it up and you’re overloaded to tow safely. I had a 21’ hybrid years ago that I was selling. I turned down a few people asking if their mini van would tow it.
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 1, 2023 20:27:47 GMT -5
660catman Thanks, I hear you but by the same token my car is not even formerly rated to tow anything in the US, if we use specs "regulations"/"requirement" to the dot. There is one type of aftermarket hitch available for my car from Curt and it's Class I and I was able to tow 3500 gross weight pop-up (with rear disc brakes on it) with this Class I hitch, which technically should not be even possible. Now Steal Hitches offer Class II for my car, which I'll be upgrading to and just having this towing experience in the past with Class I, I understand it'd be a stretch but if done carefully (watching trailer loading, distribute some weight away from the tongue, etc) maybe it's still possible to tow a 3500 lbs hybrid camper with Class II... I know I'm nickel-and-diming here but specs for 160rbt state 330lb hitch weight so 200 lbs of load on the trailer technically would put the tongue weight at capacity but then some cargo could be distributed away from the trailer front (of course with some caution for proper weight distribution).
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 1, 2023 20:57:08 GMT -5
It’s not the vehicle that’s restricted too. It’s the hitch max tongue weight of 350 lbs and you’re going to have at least 425 lbs on it. Do want you want but you’re overloaded.
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 1, 2023 21:06:33 GMT -5
660catman What if I just go light on the trailer load, why would I end up with 425 lbs on the hitch at least?
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 1, 2023 21:09:24 GMT -5
Actually, another question would a dealer who sells KZ 160rbt sell me this trailer if I have Class 2 hitch on my car? I've never bought from dealers - only private sales.
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 1, 2023 21:54:37 GMT -5
660catman What if I just go light on the trailer load, why would I end up with 425 lbs on the hitch at least? Battery and propane tank. Doesn’t matter if you lighten load in trailer. You still have the tongue weight and TW can’t be less than 10% of trailer weight. It will adversely affect handling.
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 1, 2023 21:55:08 GMT -5
Actually, another question would a dealer who sells KZ 160rbt sell me this trailer if I have Class 2 hitch on my car? I've never bought from dealers - only private sales. If they’re reputable, no.
|
|
luscombet8f
Weekender RV’er
My 1949 Luscombe T8-F & 251RLT
Posts: 68
|
Post by luscombet8f on May 1, 2023 22:06:12 GMT -5
You seem a bit shy on SAYING what your proposed TV actually is... and for me after living in both CA and NV for while... I have observed quite a few "German vehicles" and their entitled drivers... a good many of them want their problems to belong to Others. I'm not impressed. But go ahead, just do what you want without dragging others into your issue. What good it will do you to solicit opinions on the internet... in the event you DO have troubles... well, it isn't clear to me... What sometimes works for one person doesn't work for others.
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 1, 2023 23:00:34 GMT -5
luscombet8f Hmm. Pretty presumptuous and rude to lump “German vehicle” drivers as entitled drivers without knowing a person and his/her personal situation and means. If you don’t have thoughts/recommendations of value to share no one is forcing you to comment. No one is dragging anyone into “my problem”. I’m simply seeking an opinion/ideas/thoughts. Ultimately I’ll be making a decision and will be responsible what to tow or not to tow, and how to tow it, not anyone else. And I’m definitely not here to impress you. You are free to ignore the thread if you don’t have anything worthy to say on the topic other than throwing insults and bigotry.
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 2, 2023 0:04:42 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by nvguy on May 2, 2023 0:11:09 GMT -5
Exceeding manufacturers recommendations is never a good idea, as we all know there is a safety factor built in, but we don't know how much. One thing to keep in mind is crash standards are different for the U.S. VS the rest of the world, and this might be why the US model of your vehicle isn't approved for towing. Some bends or holes in the structure allow it to meet U.S. crash standards may weaken it for towing. Same thing with emission standards, it may overheat or overstress the drivetrain while towing. There are reasons why the U.S. model isn't recommended for towing. Moving things around to lessen tongue weight is going to be tricky, as two things cause sway; to much tongue weight and to little tongue weight. And lets not overlook you have only towed pop ups, not a lot of side surface area there. Get hit with a good cross wind and hang on. Based on all this I am going to assume that sway might be possible and since you're probably going to be exceeding the vehicle's capacity, any amount of sway will quickly get out of hand and it doesn't take a lot of imagination to figure out what happens next. Much as I don't want to discourage a sale for KZ, I don't think your proposed combination is safe
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 2, 2023 0:11:29 GMT -5
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 2, 2023 0:41:52 GMT -5
nvguy thank you for the feedback. The towing capacity of my vehicle is expected to be ~4400lbs - we’ve owned it for over 5 years and have towed with it since 2019. It’s 2016 E350 Wagon 4matic AWD w/40k miles on it now. Again, the after market hitches formally exist and are available for sale in the US for this car so it’s not like I’m the only one towing with this type of vehicle. As I mentioned Stealth Hitch company sells class 2 hitch. Curt sells class 1 only (Uhaul installs it). I once towed Jayco pop-up with gross weight of 3500 (not sure if it was loaded that much but dry weight would have been 2800) and dry hitch of 280 and we didn’t have issues (4-5 hr trip each way). Good point about flat surface of hard shells vs pop-ups - i haven’t considered that — I wouldn’t know how it’d tow since I’ve never tried… Would sway control bars be recommended?
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 2, 2023 6:07:48 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 2, 2023 6:12:43 GMT -5
This is about light weight trailers. You still need the proper vehicle/hitch combo to pull them. As nvguy noted, you can get into dangerous situations quickly.
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 2, 2023 6:34:57 GMT -5
One thing not noted but talked about more in a truck forum I follow is payload capacity. Every vehicle has a capacity for cargo and passengers. This is noted on the tags usually in the door post or on drivers door. Any tongue weight reduces this capacity. Say your vehicle has a 900 lb capacity and you have a tongue weight of 450 lbs. That leaves 450 for you and any passengers and all cargo inside. Vehicles also have a GCVWR which is the combined weight of vehicle and the trailer being towed.
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 2, 2023 9:58:12 GMT -5
660catman yes, I've been looking at the payload capacity as well. And thanks for all the responses 660catman and nvguy. Assuming I'm not exceeding manufacturer recommendations for my TV, I don't understand why a camper with the specs below (like the Hummingbird) can't be towed with Class 2 hitch. The hitch weight is fairly low, dry weight is 2500 lbs. From what I'm gathering it sounds like no one here so far would want any hybrid camper to be towed with Class 2. With proper brakes and hook-ups if we take the specs below and Class 2 hitch specs a vehicle with max towing capacity of 4400 lbs should be able to tow a trailer below with no issues, though 660catman you are indicating that'd be a no-go. What might I still be missing in this case? Maybe not the most optimal setup and experienced RV'ers would opt for Class 3 TV and hitch but shouldn't this be acceptable to tow this with Class 2 TV and hitch IF class 3 setup are not an option/not available? P.S. Not trying to convince myself that it's okay but truly trying to figure out what I might still be missing Dry Hitch Weight (lbs) 270 Unloaded Vehicle Weight (lbs) 2,535 Cargo Carrying Capacity (lbs) 965 Gross Vehicle Weight Rating (lbs) 3,500 Regarding gust winds, I'd say that'd be something to consider sort of separately -- I get caught up in gust winds and when passing semi trucks on a highway when pulling my pop-up now (not fun but I tackle it carefully) -- don't know what the experience would be with a hardshell hybrid until I try. Well, actually I towed a Cricket with Class 1 hitch on my wagon before taxaoutdoors.com/habitats/cricket/ and it's not apples-to-apples comparison - rented it once before purchasing our current pop-up - it's a hardshell and is a higher profile than a typical pop-up -- towing it was a breeze, supper easy and very stable (of course it's pretty light weight too) Thanks again!
|
|
mmm
Newbie RV’er
Posts: 13
|
Post by mmm on May 2, 2023 10:08:37 GMT -5
But sounds like my dream of towing EZ 160 with my wagon may have to die for now...Sadness. Uh oh. I don't want to let go of our wagon either...it works so well for a family with 4 kids and it's a "smaller" profile 7-seater for the life/parking (which is challenging) in the city.
I definitely need a roomy light weight camper and while our current pop-up works for us it is a pain to set it up and down every time. Plus, I'd like to be able to fully set up the camper by myself, it's challenging for a woman like me (I'm on the petite side) to set up and take down a pop-up up on her own. I can tow fine ha (and I've towed all of our campers) but setup/takedowns is a different story... I thought the hybrid trailer would just be it for us.
|
|
|
Post by 660catman on May 2, 2023 11:36:59 GMT -5
A class 2 hitch is 350 TW / 3500 lb capacity. A equalizer hitch will help immensely and the type with sway control will only help more. However you are pushing the limits of your TV. Doing this without HD cooling and a external transmission cooler may harm the vehicle. I remember my 93 Ford Explorer had a tow capacity but it also had a limit of square footage of front of camper due to wind drag. Towing a pop-up is a breeze. Towing sheets of plywood head on or with a side wind is not. Like I say, your vehicle, your call.
|
|